Eggs, baskets and diversified SMSF investment strategies

The ATO wants to ensure that, when an SMSF has a significant majority of its investments in a single asset class, the trustees have considered, as part of the investment strategy, the risks which could arise from that limited diversification.

 

 

Through the course of this article, we will consider the ATO requirements of SMSF trustees, and the auditor of the fund, regarding the issue of diversification of fund investments.

Is “having all of your SMSF eggs in the one basket” permitted?

The short answer is, yes. There is no legislative prohibition on the nature or proportion of the investments an SMSF may hold, although there are some additional requirements imposed if the SMSF holds certain assets, such as:

  • collectible and personal use assets,
  • units in a related unit trust, and
  • an investment made under a limited recourse borrowing arrangement.

While an SMSF trustee may hold virtually any investment available, there are legislative requirements concerning the formulation, and regular review, of the investment strategy of the SMSF, and this brings us back to the earlier reference to the ATO.

In August 2019, the ATO wrote to about 17,700 SMSF trustees (approx. 3 per cent of all SMSFs), as well as fund auditors, regarding what we have referred to earlier as “having all of your eggs in the one basket” — more formally referred to as the limited diversification of investments of those SMSFs.

Although the intent of the ATO correspondence was to remind trustees of the fact that the lack of diversification should be formally considered, an unfortunate component of the letter (at an early stage in the letter) was reference to penalties for non-compliance.

That overshadowed the intent behind the letters: to remind trustees and auditors of the requirements for the proper formulation of an investment strategy for their SMSF.

SMSF investment strategy requirements

The superannuation legislation requires that SMSF trustees [SIS Act s 52B(2)(f) and SIS Reg. 4.09(2)]:

  • “… formulate, review regularly and give effect to an investment strategy that has regard to the whole of the circumstances of the entity including…:

    (b) the composition of the entity’s investments as a whole, including the extent to which they are diverse or involve exposure of the entity to risks from inadequate diversification.”

So, while there is little stopping the SMSF trustee from lacking diversification in the investments of the SMSF, the trustee needs to have considered the various risks that may arise from that lack of diversification.

What circumstances may arise where it is likely there will be a lack of diversification?

A number of instances will occur in SMSFs which may result in the fund having significant exposure to one asset class, including:

  • the SMSF trustees know and trust investments in property, to the exclusion of other investment options;
  • the fund members invest in a variety of investments outside of the SMSF, and their aim for the SMSF is limited to holding a specific type of investment;
  • the fund members have most of their super in a public offer fund, but use the SMSF to hold an investment type, such as property, not available in the public offer fund;
  • for risk purposes, a decision may have been made to “quarantine” a real estate investment (such as a factory) in a second SMSF, so as not to risk the other SMSF in the event of a damages claim;
  • owners of a business establish an SMSF to hold the property from which their business operates, while each also has their own SMSF with their spouse; and
  • all available funds are applied to minimise the amount borrowed to acquire an asset under a limited recourse borrowing arrangement, with the eventual aim of broadening the investment range in the future.

Should trustees do anything to rectify the limited diversification?

Not necessarily. As mentioned, the lack of diversification is not the actual issue — the issue is whether the trustee of the SMSF has, as part of the creation or review of the investment strategy, provided adequate consideration to:

  • the extent to which the fund investments are diverse, and
  • the risks, including potential liquidity issues, from limited diversification.

Effectively, for trustees to be able to prove they have considered the potential risks of limited diversification, they will not only need to have a written investment strategy, but also written confirmation that the apparent lack of diversification, and resultant risks, have been considered.

Therefore, ensuring the investment strategy is up to date and that consideration has been given to the effects of any limited diversification is important.

Would planning for the future be beneficial?

Part of the risk from limited diversification is the forced action resulting from unexpected occurrences.

To plan for such eventualities is an important component of the role a prudent trustee would perform.

In the SMSF environment, that is generally referred to as an “exit strategy”.

Instances where an exit strategy would be of use include:

  • the situation of a two-member SMSF with a limited recourse borrowing arrangement, and planning for the occurrence of death, disability or divorce;
  • an agreement of business owners in the example covered earlier which could cater for the splitting of the business or the death or disability of a member, including a process to deal with the asset without causing an adverse impact.

Regardless of the ATO requirements, it is important for SMSF trustees to consider the risks which may arise from limited diversification, and the focus on those risks can be beneficial in formulating plans to mitigate any adverse impact.

How can trustees ensure they comply with the ATO requirements?

Step 1 in ensuring compliance is to confirm that the SMSF has a current investment strategy, as that is one of the covenants (the “non-negotiables”) under which SMSFs must operate.

Step 2 is to ensure that it is reviewed regularly — the ATO view is that regularly means at least annually.

Step 3 involves the specific considerations the trustee needs to cover in each review, including:

  • the investment risk and likely return;
  • the liquidity of the investments, having regard to cash flow requirements;
  • the ability to discharge current and future liabilities;
  • whether the trustee should hold insurance for the members; and
  • the composition of the “… investments as a whole, including the extent to which they are diverse or involve exposure… to risks from inadequate diversification”.

Formally undertaking a review of the investment strategy at least annually, such as when the SMSF financial statements have been prepared, with the review

  • ensuring the fund investments are within any parameters set out in the investment strategy, and
  • covering the matters detailed in Step 3 above, with particular attention to the diversification aspect, if applicable

will see the trustee effectively covering not only the ATO requirements but also meeting the specific covenant concerning SMSF investments.

More considerations

Mentioned earlier was the fact that some SMSF auditors had also received correspondence from the ATO. That occurred if they had audited an SMSF which has more than 90 per cent of its assets in a single asset class.

The correspondence effectively put auditors on notice to ensure trustees have given adequate consideration to the diversification issues we have covered in this article.

As a result, trustees can expect increased auditor scrutiny of their investment strategy documentation, including the diversification considerations.

Documentation

An anomaly with the investment strategy legislation is that, while the trustee of the SMSF must have an investment strategy, there is no stipulated requirement that it be in writing.

The same applies to the diversification considerations.

However, it would be a very brave trustee who did not support their decisions with proper documents as, without written proof, it is likely the auditor and the ATO will deem that no such investment strategy exists.

Topdocs recommends that an investment strategy be regularly reviewed and, if necessary, it be updated so as to ensure it remains reflective of the trustee’s intentions.

Additionally, if the investments are limited in their diversification, trustee resolutions confirming their deliberations of the risks involved must be prepared.

Conclusion

Having eggs in the one basket is permitted, but trustees need to have considered the risks and difficulties involved.

SMSF trustees have much to think about in the administration of their fund — the degree of diversification of investments is one consideration they should properly document.

 

 

Michael Harkin
27 November 2019
smsfadviser.com

 

Want to know more?

Do you have a question about something you've read in this article? Need more information? Want to book an appointment? Simply let us know below and we'll get back to you ASAP.

Secure File Transfer is a facility that allows the safe and secure exchange of confidential files or documents between you and us.

Email is very convenient in our business world, there is no doubting that. However email messages and attachments can be intercepted by third parties, putting your privacy and identity at risk if used to send confidential files or documents. Secure File Transfer eliminates this risk.

Login to Secure File Transfer below, or contact us if you require a username and password.

Please enjoy the links to these free tools supplied by MoneySmart - a great resource for general financial information. Please get in touch if you would like to discuss any questions that you may have as a result of using these calculators.

Privacy Policy Statement

GCR Financial Pty Ltd
AFSL 333543
ABN 61 133 869 182

April 2014

Our commitment

GCR Financial (GCR) recognizes that your privacy is very important to you – it is to us as well. We handle personal information provided by and about people every day. By personal information we mean information or an opinion about a person whose identity is apparent or can reasonably be ascertained.

The aim of GCR is both to support and to ensure that it complies with the National Privacy Principles (NPPs) that form the basis of laws introduced to strengthen privacy protection for the general public including its members. GCR also seeks to comply with the Spam Act that is aimed at reducing the number of unsolicited electronic commercial messages that you receive.

We believe that this Statement will address any potential concerns you may have about how personal information you provide is collected, held, used, corrected, disclosed and transferred. You can obtain more information on request about the way we manage the personal information we hold. If you seek any further information please contact us in one of the ways set out below.

Collection

In the course of our activities we collect and hold personal information of our clients. Our main purposes for collecting that personal information include to assess the financial needs and requirements of our clients, to update our records and for marketing purposes.

We will only collect personal information from you that is necessary to assess your personal financial planning needs.

We will only collect personal information from you by lawful and fair means, without being unreasonably intrusive, such as when you complete an application or update form etc.

At or before the time we collect personal information from you we will take reasonable steps to inform you why we are collecting that personal information, who else we might disclose that personal information to and what will happen if you do not provide personal information to us.

Where reasonable and practicable, we will only collect personal information about you, from you.

Wherever it is lawful and practicable, we will give you the option of not identifying yourself or not providing personal information when dealing with us. However, failure to provide full and complete information we request may mean that we are unable to provide services to you fully and properly.

Once we hold personal information we will take reasonable steps to keep it accurate, complete and up-to-date.

Use and disclosure

We will only use your personal information for the main purpose we told you it was needed for, except where you consent to us using that personal information for another purpose, where the other purpose is related to the main purpose and you would reasonably expect us to use the personal information for that other purpose, or where it is permitted or required by law, or we reasonably believe it is necessary on health or public safety grounds to use the personal information for another purpose.

In relation to direct marketing, where practicable we will seek your consent before we use your personal information for this purpose. You may tell us at any time you do not wish to receive any further direct marketing materials – if you do, we will stop sending you such materials.

In accordance with the Spam Act, should you wish to unsubscribe from commercial electronic messages from GCR, all future commercial electronic messages from GCR will enable you to unsubscribe from that particular type of electronic message and this can be done at any time. If you do not unsubscribe, GCR will continue to send you relevant information of the types described above.

We will not adopt as our own any identifiers that you may provide to us such as Tax File Numbers etc.

Access and correction

If you ask, we will tell you what personal information we hold about you, and what we do with it. We will facilitate access to you by allowing an inspection of your personal information in person, or by providing copies or a summary of relevant documents, depending on what is most appropriate in the circumstances, following receipt of your request.

If you can show us that the personal information is inaccurate, we will take reasonable steps to correct it. Note that we need not provide access to personal information in several types of situation, for example where a request is frivolous, or where to provide access would pose a threat to health or public safety, unreasonably interfere with another person’s privacy, or be a breach of the law. If we refuse access we will advise you of our reasons for doing so.

Security

We will protect personal information from misuse and loss, and destroy or permanently de-identify personal information we no longer need.

Complaints resolution

We are committed to providing clients, whose personal information we hold, a fair and responsible system for the handling of their complaints.

If at any time you have any complaints in relation to privacy, please contact our Complaints Officer at one of the points referred to below. We will seek to address any concerns that you have through our complaints handling processes, but if you wish to take matters further you may refer your concerns to the Financial Ombudsman Service.

Contact us

If you seek any further information from GCR about this Statement or our privacy policy generally please contact our Administration Manager at one of the reference points below:

admin@gcrfinancial.com.au

6 Davies Street Oxley QLD 4075
Telephone: 1800 854 293
Facsimile: 1800 854 295

Website Terms of Use

Terms and Conditions

Your access and use of this website constitutes your agreement to these terms of use, GCR Financial’s Privacy Policy and any other notices, disclaimers, statements and other terms and conditions contained on this website. By accessing this website and other websites through links provided by us, you agree to be subject to these terms.

This website

“This website” means all web pages located on the www.gcrfinancial.com.au domain name. This website is the website of GCR Financial Pty Ltd ABN 61 133 869 182.

The information contained on this website may not be accurate or up to date in all respects. We do not warrant the accuracy or completeness of any information contained on this website. None of GCR Financial, its related body corporate or any associate (which expression includes the directors, employees, consultants or contractors to GCR Financial) makes any representation or warranty as to the quality, accuracy, reliability, timeliness or completeness of material in this website or in material linked to this website, except in so far as liability cannot be excluded by law. GCR Financial and its associates do not accept any liability (whether arising in contract, tort, negligence or otherwise) for any error or omission in the material or for any loss or damage (whether direct, indirect, consequential or other wise and including losses that may arise due to damage to computer equipment or software or as a result of the inaccessibility of this website) suffered by the recipient of the information or user of this website or any other person.

This website may contain links to third party websites. GCR Financial and its related entities do not make any representations as to the contents of any third party websites, and are not responsible for an will not be liable for the content of any third party websites.

You release, discharge and indemnify GCR Financial and its associates from and against any and all liabilities suffered or incurred by you as a result of use of this website.

General information only

The information contained in this website should be used as general information only. It does not take into account the particular circumstances, needs or objectives of any client, or purport to be comprehensive or constitute personal advice and should not be relied upon as such. You should consult our licensed financial advisers to help you form your own opinion of the information, and as to whether the information is suitable for your individual needs and aims. You should consult appropriate professional advisers on any legal, stamp duty, taxation and accounting implications of making a financial decision.

Privacy

GCR Financial is committed to respecting your privacy and takes all reasonable steps to protect the personal information we collect from you. This policy is based on the Australian Privacy Principles (APPs) as per Schedule 1 of the Privacy Amendment (Enhancing Privacy Protection) Act 2012.

We may, as a result of your access to this website, hold and process personal information obtained about you. However, GCR Financial is committed to maintaining the privacy of any personal data it holds about you, and does so in accordance with the APPs. Please read GCR Financial’s Privacy Policy to understand how your personal information will be treated when you use this website.

We may disclose your personal information to third parties that help us deliver our services (including information technology suppliers, communication suppliers and our business partners) or as required by law.

Our Privacy Policy explains: (a) how we store and use, and how you may access and correct your personal information; (b) how you can lodge a complaint regarding the handling of your personal information; and (c) how we will handle any complaint.

By providing your personal information to us, you consent to the collection, use, storage and disclosure of that information as described in the Privacy Policy and these terms.

Copyright, trademarks and intellectual property rights

Unless expressly stated, GCR Financial is the owner or licensed user of the copyright and any intellectual property rights in any material, design, technology or concept contained on this website. All rights are reserved. You may use the information for your own personal reference only. You may reproduce the information in hard copy solely for your personal use. Except as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) or other applicable laws, this website or any portion of this website may not otherwise be reproduced, adapted, distributed, displayed or transmitted to any other person or incorporated in any way into another document or other material, without GCR Financial’s express consent.

Linked sites

Our website may contain links to websites operated by third parties. Those links are provided for convenience and may not remain current or maintained. Unless expressly stated otherwise, we do not endorse and are not responsible for the content on those linked websites and have no control over or rights in those linked websites.

Disclaimer

This website may contain advice. Any advice is of a general nature and is not based on your personal objectives, your financial situation and needs. Accordingly, you should consider how appropriate any advice is to personal objectives, financial situation and needs. Before acquiring any financial product or service, you should read both our Financial Services Guide (FSG) from GCR Financial and any relevant Product Disclosure Statements (PDS) from product providers.

Any advice provided on this website is provided by the Australian Financial Services Licensee GCR Financial Pty Ltd (AFS & ACL 333543). GCR Financial accepts no liability for acting on this advice for who is not the intended recipient.